Linux: Making the jump from Photoshop to GIMP

opinion
Sep 24, 20158 mins

In today's open source roundup: A redditor switches from Photoshop to GIMP. Plus: Tails 1.6 released. And GNOME 3.18 Gothenburg is out

Switching from Photoshop to GIMP

Photoshop is one of the most used image editing applications around. But how easy is it for a user to switch from Photoshop to the GIMP when they move from a Mac to Linux? A redditor is doing just that and wanted some feedback from his fellow Linux users.

M2zero asked his question:

I’m looking at getting a new home computer. my Mac died a few months ago and I’m looking at going full linux for a desktop workstation. So my question is has anyone one switch fully over from photoshop to Gimp and inkscape? How was the transition, do you feel limited, any other comments or thoughts. Now I have used gimp a few times, I’ve edited photos fixed things up, I just havent spent a massive amount of time on it and used it in production.

Bit of a background, I’m a 3D artist. I’m fine with the rest of the software stack on linux for my needs, the only issue is Photoshop, I’ll be using gimp for texture editing and general graphic design stuff.

More at Reddit

His fellow Linux redditors responded with their thoughts:

Bull500: ”Well if you’re into painting, i would recommend Krita.There is no limits to what its capable of now and into the future.

If you’re into vectors – inkscape is all you need. I’ve used it a lot and its pretty awesome as well.

Now that leaves us with GIMP – Is it good? Yes. But like any other software, empty your head and explore it first. It can be quite intimidating, but once your know your way around it. So just practice around and let the flow work itself way out.”

Uoou: ”It’s a mixed bag really. I never particularly liked Photoshop, I don’t think it has a particularly good UI, same for Illustrator. But I knew them, so there’s a lot of familiarity to get over and muscle memory to unlearn and relearn. I actually think The Gimp has a better UI than PS but it’s frustrating having to learn a new tool to do stuff you can already do.

While the Gimp’s UI might be alright, it’s definitely lacking in features for advanced use. Particularly the non-destructive editing stuff. If what you’re doing is more along the lines of image creation than photo manipulation then you might be better off with Krita[1] . It’s pretty promising already and seems to see far more rapid development than The Gimp.

Inkscape is kinda the opposite of The Gimp in that it’s incredibly powerful – it can do anything – but it has a pretty bad UI, everything is just kinda dumped on the screen on the same level. To be fair, again, Illustrator has a pretty awful UI as well, I think with programs of this complexity it’s just hard to do good UIs (although Freehand was lovely to use. Until Adobe killed it). The more time I spend in Inkscape the more I like it though, once you learn the key combos and stuff the UI is largely irrelevant anyway. It’s rough around the edges, without a doubt, but it’s a good piece of software.

I assume you’re using Blender for 3D modelling? Blender is great. In fact I think it’s the best piece of FOSS creativity software produced to date and I actually much prefer it over its proprietary rivals. Again, it takes some learning as it does things differently and it lags behind in terms of the very most advanced features but for 99.9% of what anyone would want to do with it, it’s there.

So yeah, switching is honestly hard work. I did it largely for ideological reasons (I just think free software is a better way to live) and would probably otherwise have given up. But now I’m settled in I’d find it hard to go back, no doubt as hard as switching was. The FOSS creativity apps may be rough around the edges but they’re more flexible, far more stable (PS used to crash a lot, I’ve literally never experienced a crash in Gimp, Krita, Inkscape or Blender) and perform better. ”

Raghukamath: ”For 3d texturing I would suggest a combination of Krita and gimp. Krita has awesome tools to create seamless tiles and textures. Gimp can be used for post processing and manipulation. For graphic design stuff Inkscape and gimp would be fit. If you need to design for print, such as book Scribus does the job.

The fact is Linux has various apps targeting small workflows like digital painting, graphic design etc. Photoshop is jack of all trades. You need to adjust your workflow by combining two or three apps on Linux to achieve what you want.

You’ll succeed if you are not afraid of find things and learning new UI, the basic are the same it’s just that options and menu are different.”

LeStr4berry: ”If you are into texture editing and graphic design, check out Krita. Krita’s wrap-around mode is a God-send for texture makers, and its robust set of features (great brush engines, transform tools, perspective assistants, clone layers, symmetry modes, multi-brushes, bezier selections, layer styles, G’MIC plugin support, and so on and so forth) made me say goodbye to Photoshop some time ago.

The way the brushes work might be a bit confusing at first, but once you learn how to create your own, the sky is the limit (oddly enough, what I initially missed the most were the basic Photoshop brushes – I ended up re-creating them in Krita). Until then, there are some nice brush packs available for download (David Revoy, AKA Deevad has some great ones available on his Deviantart and website).”

Sssam: ”Gimp has some very powerful plug-ins, Resynthesizer and liquid rescale. They are probably in you linux distributions package manager.”

Asekcilw: ”I learned gimp and later tried to transition to photoshop and made many of the same complains photoshop users had for gimp. Everything will be in the wrong place and some of your workflows will need slight adjustments, but otherwise you should be fine.”

Veritasserum: ”I have been a silver photographer for many decades. I use digital only for very small pieces of my work. That said, the only thing GIMP still does not have is 16 bit processing. Then again, I haven’t got a camera that can do 16 bit RAW anyway.

If you are really diligent, you might be able to stress GIMP beyond your needs 1% of the time, but I doubt it. For almost all of the usual applications, the limitation will be you, not the tool.”

More at Reddit

Tails 1.6 released

If privacy is important to you than Tails is something you should consider using on your computer. Version 1.6 has just been released, so now is a good time to check it out.

If you aren’t familiar with Tails, the Tails site has a good description on its about page:

Tails is a live system that aims to preserve your privacy and anonymity. It helps you to use the Internet anonymously and circumvent censorship almost anywhere you go and on any computer but leaving no trace unless you ask it to explicitly.

It is a complete operating system designed to be used from a DVD, USB stick, or SD card independently of the computer’s original operating system. It is Free Software and based on Debian GNU/Linux.

Tails comes with several built-in applications pre-configured with security in mind: web browser, instant messaging client, email client, office suite, image and sound editor, etc.

More at Tails

The tails site also has details on what’s in version 1.6:

Upgrade Tor Browser to version 5.0.3 (based on Firefox 38.3.0 ESR).

Upgrade I2P to version 0.9.22 and enable its AppArmor profile.

There are numerous other changes that might not be apparent in the daily operation of a typical user. Technical details of all the changes are listed in the Changelog.

More at Tails

GNOME 3.18 released

GNOME 3.18 has been in development for a while, but now it has been released by the GNOME developers. This release includes the integration of Google Drive into Nautilus, as well as numerous other changes.

Silviu Stahie reports for Softpedia:

The integration of Google Drive into Nautilus is probably the feature that will draw the most attention, even if there is a lot of other stuff in 3.18. This has been achieved in a very straightforward manner, by adding an entry, like a bookmark, right into Nautilus, which is the default file manager. Users will just have to add the Google account to Online Accounts, and they should be set.

Another big component that received a swath of new features and various improvements is Files (former Nautilus). For example, a new location named Other, which points towards local and network locations, has been added in the “Save as” dialog, the Copy or Move dialog has been refined and it provides more details (still no pause option), context menus are now available on touch screens with just a long press, recursive search has been automatically disabled for remote locations, and the drag and drop function has been improved.

The new Calendar application that was only available as a preview in GNOME 3.16 is now completely integrated into the current release, and it’s also linked with GNOME Online Accounts.

More at Softpedia

Did you miss a roundup? Check the Eye On Open home page to get caught up with the latest news about open source and Linux.

jim_lynch

Jim Lynch is a technology analyst and online community manager.

Jim has written for many leading industry publications over the years, including ITworld, InfoWorld, CIO, PCMag, ExtremeTech, and numerous others.

Before becoming a writer, Jim started his career as an online community manager. He managed Ziff Davis’ forums on CompuServe and the web including the PCMag and ExtremeTech forums. He’s also done community management gigs with the Family Education Network, Popular Mechanics and MSN Games. Jim still has a passion for well-moderated discussion forums that offer helpful information without a lot of flames, rudeness and noise.

You can visit Jim’s personal blog, view his LinkedIn profile, or send him an email to share your thoughts.

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of Jim Lynch and do not necessarily represent those of IDG Communications, Inc., its parent, subsidiary or affiliated companies.

More from this author