Is Linux Mint a terrible desktop distribution?

opinion
Nov 20, 20157 mins

In today's open source roundup: A redditor shares his horror at how...er...awful Linux Mint is as a desktop distribution. Plus: 5 memory debuggers for Linux coding. And how to customize the KDE Linux desktop

Is Linux Mint a terrible desktop distribution?

How bad is Linux Mint as a desktop distribution? One redditor shared his…er…frustration with the…er…horrifically difficult experience of installing Linux Mint on his computer.

Itripovermyownfeet shared his thoughts in the Linux Mint subreddit:

This is awful, when I install Linux on the desktop I’m expecting to be able to waste a solid 8 hours chasing down random issues that were solved on all other modern desktop systems by 2008. I went into this hoping and wishing to have to crawl through linuxquestions.org threads from 2006 to figure out why plugging in a second monitor doesn’t work with X.org.

I want the peace and quiet that you can only get from spending 45 minutes trying to get alsa/oss/flavor of the week sound manager to work properly. I miss the subtle delicious pain of trying to figure out what I have to do to get Gnome 3 or Unity to provide desktop functionality that came standard with Windows NT 4.

With what you’ve done here I am no longer able to do any of these things. You’ve taken the awful travesty of an experience that trying to do anything production on a Linux desktop is supposed to provide and made it usable, sensible, and working out of the box. This is why I can’t call Mint a Linux desktop. It’s just a desktop… you monsters.

(I plugged a second monitor into my HDMI slot and it just worked. I have literally never experienced that since working with Linux since the days of Redhat 3. You’ve taken away a cherished time honoured tradition of having a terrible experience using a Linux desktop from me forever.)

More at Reddit

His fellow redditors shared their…er…anguish at having to deal with Linux Mint too:

AusMattyBoy: ”Talk about clickbait, was about to unleash the fury, was not necessary lol”

Gandalfx: ”I almost fell for the same trap, but I’ve been burnt before and the high number of up votes tipped be of. He is not the first who infuriatingly robbed others of the joys of counter hating. How dare he!

Could “reverse trolling” be an appropriate term for this?

@OP I feel your pain (kind of) but there is still hope: You can install an alternative desktop / window manager and still spend some good hours getting it to work the way you want. Bonus points for a tiling wm. ^^”

NotFromReddit: ”I’m so sleep deprived, I got half way into the post before realizing it’s a joke.”

Crcr: ”I know what you mean, Mint has been this way for me since version 12 & it’s starting to get old, the usability out of the box drives me nuts.”

Bomberokmn: ”A decade and a half ago, I really enjoyed setting up Slackware from almost scratch. I learned a lot, and wouldn’t trade that experience for anything.

Now, I have more interests and obligations. I don’t have hours to spend hacking away at the keyboard, trying to make some janky kernel module work so that I can run X on an onboard video card. Seeing Linux mature to a point where I can download an ISO, send it to a USB drive, reboot and have a fully functional system in under half an hour is incredible.”

Colonelpanic420: ”Mint is a fantastic distro if you just want to run linux, not spend a ton of time setting it up, and go. It was my go-to for my work machine for a while. Not because I wasn’t familiar with other distros, I just because I could set it up and not have to tweak it too much to get to a point where I can do my job, and off I go.

Though Mint doesn’t get to take all the credit for things “just working” – a lot of that is because the kernel drivers are so much better than they were when we all started messing with this crap 20 years ago or whatever (well that’s me anyway ymmv.)

I got bagged on for using Mint for a while by co-workers who had spent the time to setup their favorite distros just the way they wanted them and I’m like eh I got stuff to do bruh ain’t no time to get that i3/config file just the way I want it for my preferred user experience. Xfce will do just fine lol.

That said, Arch and sid are the Sonny and Cher of my heart.”

Foofly: ”I tried to explain to a friend that the installation experience is better than Windows these days. In addition to having way less driver issues in general. He didn’t believe me since his last experience was almost 10 years ago”

Introspeck: ”Early Fedora installs used to have me literally screaming in rage. My wife would stay well away from me for the 8 hours it took to finally get it working.”

Okko7: ”Whenever I install on a new machine, I’m bored because there is nothing to fix anymore.”

Rxke2: ”I actually checked his history to see if he was a troll… To discover, no, not at all. (Of course I only had read the title at that point, heehee) ”

More at Reddit

5 memory debuggers for Linux coding

A programmer at Computerworld has a very helpful roundup of five memory debuggers.

Himanshu Arora reports for Computerworld:

As a programmer, I’m aware that I tend to make mistakes — and why not? Even programmers are human. Some errors are detected during code compilation, while others get caught during software testing. However, a category of error exists that usually does not get detected at either of these stages and that may cause the software to behave unexpectedly — or worse, terminate prematurely.

If you haven’t already guessed it, I am talking about memory-related errors. Manually debugging these errors can be not only time-consuming but difficult to find and correct. Also, it’s worth mentioning that these errors are surprisingly common, especially in software written in programming languages like C and C++, which were designed for use with manual memory management.

Thankfully, several programming tools exist that can help you find memory errors in your software programs. In this roundup, I assess five popular, free and open-source memory debuggers that are available for Linux: Dmalloc, Electric Fence, Memcheck, Memwatch and Mtrace. I’ve used all five in my day-to-day programming, and so these reviews are based on practical experience.

Dmalloc

Electric Fence

Memcheck

Memwatch

Mtrace

More at Computerworld

How to customize the KDE desktop

KDE is a very popular Linux desktop, but some folks might not be aware of how to customize it. A writer at ZDNet has a helpful how-to post that shows how to change KDE to suit your personal preferences.

JA Watson reports for ZDNet:

…so this time I am going to look at KDE. Although it is overall a much larger topic, I am going to (try to) stay focused only on the desktop and how to configure/customize it. I hope will keep things to a manageable size for this post.

I will be using the KDE Plasma 5 desktop for this post, as it is the ‘current’ release; there may still be some distributions holding out with KDE 4 (I’m looking at you, PCLinuxos), so if things look totally different on your system, check your KDE version. Oh, and if you find that you are still clinging desperately to KDE 3… well, I hope that the information and examples I present here might at least convince you to finally consider upgrading.

I will take most of the examples from openSuSE, either Tumbleweed or Leap, as both are currently running Plasma 5 desktop release 5.4.2, which was the absolute latest until about a week ago.

More at ZDNet

Did you miss a roundup? Check the Eye On Open home page to get caught up with the latest news about open source and Linux.

jim_lynch

Jim Lynch is a technology analyst and online community manager.

Jim has written for many leading industry publications over the years, including ITworld, InfoWorld, CIO, PCMag, ExtremeTech, and numerous others.

Before becoming a writer, Jim started his career as an online community manager. He managed Ziff Davis’ forums on CompuServe and the web including the PCMag and ExtremeTech forums. He’s also done community management gigs with the Family Education Network, Popular Mechanics and MSN Games. Jim still has a passion for well-moderated discussion forums that offer helpful information without a lot of flames, rudeness and noise.

You can visit Jim’s personal blog, view his LinkedIn profile, or send him an email to share your thoughts.

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of Jim Lynch and do not necessarily represent those of IDG Communications, Inc., its parent, subsidiary or affiliated companies.

More from this author