Galen Gruman
Executive Editor for Global Content

Mobile security: iOS vs. Android vs. WebOS vs. the rest

analysis
Jul 19, 20114 mins

As tablets and smartphones become common business tools, InfoWorld's handy comparison helps IT know which to allow

It’s no longer a question of whether your business will support tablets and smartphones. And at most organizations, it’s no longer a question of whether you’ll support multiple mobile OSes. The question is, which mobile OSes can you support?

I’ve put together a table (on the next page) of what the mainstream mobile OSes supports for security and management, so you can tell quickly which platforms offer the fundamental capabilities you require.

Most devices — BlackBerry is the exception — use Microsoft Exchange ActiveSync (EAS) policies for their native management, so your email server and its associated Active Directory profiles become your management tool. (BlackBerry Enterprise Server, an add-on server for Exchange, GroupWise, and Lotus Notes, works essentially the same way.)

To go beyond these native capabilities or to manage mobile devices outside of Exchange, consider using a third-party mobile device management platform. These MDM platforms vary widely in capability and focus, with some oriented to providing user support — such as Boxtone — and telecom expense management, such as Tangoe. Others — such as Good for Enterprise, MobileIron, Sybase Afaria, Trellia, and Zenprise — offer a broad range of capabilities.

If your security needs are complex, you might need to look at mobile application management tools; there are products for native apps and products for HTML5 apps. You can also find mobile-aware network management tools that detect and manage access by mobile devices, including those not managed by your MDM tool.

Table: Mobile management capabilities compared

Key: EAS = via Microsoft Exchange ActiveSync. BES = via BlackBerry Enterprise Server 5.x. 3PS = via third-party server.

Capability

Apple iOS 4.x

Google Android 3.0

Google Android 2.2, 2.3

HP WebOS 3.0

HP WebOS 2.x

Microsoft Windows Mobile 6.x

Microsoft Windows Phone 7

Nokia Symbian 2.x, 3.x1

RIM BlackBerry 5.x, 6.x

On-device encryption

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes2

Yes

Over-the-air data encryption

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Complex passwords

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Enforce password policies

Yes3

EAS4

EAS4

EAS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

BES

Support VPNs

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

No

Yes

Yes

Disable camera

Yes3

No

No

No

No

EAS, 3PS

No

No

BES

Restrict/block app stores

Yes3

No

No

No

No

EAS, 3PS

No

No

BES

Restrict/block wireless LANs

Yes3

No

No

No

No

EAS, 3PS

No

No

BES

Remote lockout

Yes3

EAS, 3PS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

No

BES

Remote wipe

Yes3

EAS, 3PS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

BES

Selective wipe of business apps and data only

3PS

No

No

No

No

No

No

No

BES5

Enforce and manage policies

EAS, 3PS

EAS, 3PS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

BES

EAS policies supported

14

13 6

9 6

7

5

29 7

7

NA

none8

Manage over the air

EAS, 3PS

EAS, 3PS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

EAS

EAS, 3PS

BES

Second-factor authentication (RSA SecurID)

No

No

No

No

No

Yes9

No

No

Yes9

Notes: 1. Some Nokia E-series and N-series devices only. 2. Storage cards not encrypted. 3. Via choice of Apple iPhone Configuration Utility (no over-the-air confirmation or auditing), Mac OS X Lion Server, EAS, and 3PS. 4. Require PIN only. 5. BlackBerry OS 6 only. 6. Some third-party email client applications support additional EAS policies within those applications only. 7. Exchange Server Enterprise license required for support of all 29 EAS policies, lower-tier licenses support 15 EAS policies. 8. BES supports more than 500 policies of its own. 9. Some device models only.

This article, “Mobile security: iOS vs. Android vs. WebOS vs. the rest,” was originally published at InfoWorld.com. Read more of Galen Gruman’s Mobile Edge blog and follow the latest developments in mobile technology at InfoWorld.com. Follow Galen’s mobile musings on Twitter at MobileGalen. For the latest business technology news, follow InfoWorld.com on Twitter.