Bob Lewis
Columnist

Strategic planning frameworks

analysis
Apr 20, 20072 mins

Dear Bob Would you briefly describe what the BCG and TOWS matrices are. Then briefly tell me which might be more useful to:- (a) A new company which has just been set up to supply domestic cleaning services. (b) A company which employs 500 people and which only makes Christmas decorations. (c)The Managing Director of a large company which has been in business for 7 years and which manufactures frozen "complete

Dear Bob

Would you briefly describe what the BCG and TOWS matrices are. Then briefly tell me which might be more useful to:-

(a) A new company which has just been set up to supply domestic cleaning services. (b) A company which employs 500 people and which only makes Christmas decorations. (c)The Managing Director of a large company which has been in business for 7 years and which manufactures frozen “complete meals” for busy people.

Thanks a lot,

– Planning

Dear Planning …

BCG is named after the Boston Consulting Group. It directs businesses to go after opportunities where they can dominate fast-growing marketplaces.

Well, sure, although it doesn’t do much to guide action. It’s a magic quadrant approach useful for comparing competing ideas. I’m skeptical that it’s of much real value.

TOWS isn’t a matrix approach. It’s my variation on the old SWOT analysis (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats). I prefer TOWS because it begins with the business model – how a company faces its marketplace and works to bring revenue in the door.

I’m not going to answer your questions directly. It sounds like I might be writing a term paper for you. If not, please forgive my suspicious nature. I will provide a bit of guidance, though: TOWS (and SWOT) are useful for established businesses that are clear about which buttons they have to push and levers they have to pull for success to happen. TOWS helps them make sense of what’s changing that might affect their success.

It isn’t well-suited to newer companies that are still trying to figure it out.

I hope that helps.

– Bob

Powered by ScribeFire.