Paul Krill
Editor at Large

XML co-inventor: Now’s the time for federated identity

analysis
Nov 14, 20132 mins

Google's Tim Bray proposes an alternative to the clunky practice of choosing and maintaining multiple passwords

Rather than having Internet visitors maintain an easily forgettable bunch of passwords, Web application builders should use federated identity services, enabling users to have just a few passwords protected by entities with substantial resources in security, XML co-inventor Tim Bray argues.

With federated identity, users sign into multiple sites via accounts with a major Web providers, such as Facebook or Twitter. This, he said, enables users to create a good hard-to-remember password instead of having to recall a bunch of them. Companies like Google and Facebook employ hundreds of engineers who look for intruders, said Bray, speaking at the DevBeat conference in San Francisco this week: “You’re better off putting all your eggs in one basket and watching that basket very carefully.”

He panned the practice of having users pick and maintain passwords. “Passwords are bad. They are not your friends. They are not your users’ friends,” said Bray, developer advocate at Google. Users are subjected to cumbersome requirements, such as having to have passwords that are eight characters long, with one alpha character, he notes. “If you do this, you are being mean to people.”

Compounding the issue, typing passwords on mobile devices is a problem, he adds. “It’s a horrible, horrible experience.”

Users cannot remember passwords, so they end up having to go through password recovery via email. Or users use the same password for every site, resulting in a security issue if this password is ever stolen, Bray notes. He also cited major incidents of passwords being leaked from sites like Yahoo and LinkedIn, and the existence of online services that even sell user account data. “[Bad actors] want to get those passwords and use them on the user’s bank accounts.”

Bray cited identity technologies, including OAuth as well as OpenID, as approaches to identity. Biometric security also is emerging from companies like Lenovo, he noted.

Bray’s arguments persuaded developer Christian Hansen of CrowdCurity, which does security testing. “It makes sense to have just two or three accounts where you store your passwords,” Hansen said.

This story, “XML co-inventor: Now’s the time for federated identity,” was originally published at InfoWorld.com. Get the first word on what the important tech news really means with the InfoWorld Tech Watch blog. For the latest developments in business technology news, follow InfoWorld.com on Twitter.

Paul Krill

Paul Krill is editor at large at InfoWorld. Paul has been covering computer technology as a news and feature reporter for more than 35 years, including 30 years at InfoWorld. He has specialized in coverage of software development tools and technologies since the 1990s, and he continues to lead InfoWorld’s news coverage of software development platforms including Java and .NET and programming languages including JavaScript, TypeScript, PHP, Python, Ruby, Rust, and Go. Long trusted as a reporter who prioritizes accuracy, integrity, and the best interests of readers, Paul is sought out by technology companies and industry organizations who want to reach InfoWorld’s audience of software developers and other information technology professionals. Paul has won a “Best Technology News Coverage” award from IDG.

More from this author